What this is about
Take your HR business partner's diary from last month. How much of it was about how the work in a department is divided, and how much about a vacancy text, a job description or a file that had to be finished?
If that balance is off, it is rarely down to the person. The role was devised to make the line more capable, and it gets swallowed by work the line would do itself. Nobody does anything wrong there. It is a loop, and it keeps turning on its own.
How the loop turns
HR puts a piece of work with the line. That is called devolution and it is a defensible choice. Whoever knows the team can judge that team better than someone who does not.
Only that work now sits with ten, twenty or fifty line managers. Each of them writes a vacancy text a few times a year. That is too little to build any routine. So the line manager calls the partner, with a request that is operational and in a hurry. The partner finds it hard to say no, takes it on, and the threshold for calling next time drops a little further.
They can do it. They do it too rarely.
That distinction is the whole point. Researchers followed a health and social care organisation with more than ten thousand staff and call this a vicious cycle. The tasks are spread over too many people to become routine for any of them, and the request for help that follows pulls the partner back into transactional work. Twenty-two interviews and six focus groups, in one organisation.
That is why training does not help. Training solves a knowledge problem and this is not one. Whoever writes a job description three times a year starts again every time, however good that training was.
Three ways to break the loop
They do not rule each other out, and which one fits depends on where it gets stuck with you.
Bundle the work until there is repetition in it
Not everything back to HR, but into fewer hands. A few people who do it often enough to get good at it, with the departments divided among them. Then the work is no longer put with everyone but with someone, and that someone does build routine. Do work out what that bundling costs in distance to the department, because that is exactly what devolution set out to gain.
Give away the decision and the means together
Devolution gives the task to the line and often leaves the judgement with HR. Then the line manager has the responsibility and not the authority, and so the phone rings back. Give both or neither. That is the same imbalance that sits under every seam: the demand lands where the capacity to do something about it has just been taken away.
Put a date on the support
The partner role is almost nowhere meant to be temporary and has almost everywhere become permanent. Agree at the start how you will see that the line can do it alone, and when you will check that. Without that date it never ends, because by then the department can no longer do without it and the partner is on a permanent contract.
Who writes the vacancy text at your organisation, and who decides on the content of the job?
And if that is not the same person, who gets called the moment it is not a standard case?
What you do not simply move
Shifting work back and forth between HR and the line looks like an internal matter. It is not always.
If the change touches the organisation of work itself, the works council has to be informed and consulted before the decision is taken, not after. In Belgium the commentary to article 10 of collective agreement no. 9 names organisational change, the division of tasks and a change to the organisation chart in so many words.
And if the shift touches the content of someone's job, the motive does not count. That you are redistributing to make the organisation run better changes nothing about whether you are unilaterally altering an essential element of the employment contract.
That is no reason to drop it. You only have to know the order before you start.
What you can check yourself
- How many line managers at your organisation do the same HR task, and how often does each of them do it?
- Is it written down anywhere when the support for a department ends?
- Does the line manager who got the task also have the authority to decide on it?
- Can the partner point to a week in which they did get to the real work?
- Of the last three calls, do you know why the line called instead of doing it themselves?
Five times no is no disgrace. It only says the role was never designed, and that everyone has been doing their best in it ever since.
When this helps
This helps when your HR business partners are busy and you cannot point to what with. And above all when you are about to take on another one because the current ones cannot cope. Look at the loop above first, because an extra partner makes the loop bigger and not shorter. If you cannot tell whether it is the bundling, the authority or the end date in your case, start with the end date. It is the cheapest one to set and it exposes the other two by itself.