Model

The steering group attendance list

Whoever sits at the same table every month is the map of a team your organisation chart does not have. Whether you call that a board or a team makes no difference. The question is whether that table removes the capacity to act from the place where the demands land.

the table decides the same table decision another unit more demands, less room
If the table decides what has to happen elsewhere, the demands rise there while the room moves to the table.
the table understands the same table insight the unit decides demands and room stay together
If it brings insight and the unit decides for itself, demands and room stay together.

What this is about

Take the invitation to your last steering group and look only at the names. Which departments sit there together every month? And do those same people speak to each other about this work outside that table?

If the answer to that second question is no, you are holding the map of a team that does not exist. The organisation found the right lenses long ago. It just turned them into a meeting instead of a working group.

A table like that rarely appears out of nowhere. It is an answer to a boundary nobody drew, which work still has to cross. That is what we call a seam, and where it comes from is in The seam in the org chart.

Why that table appears

A table is built faster than a way of working. In Belgian research into IT governance at financial institutions, the IT steering committee sits at the top of the minimal baseline of practices, and the participants call such bodies far easier to set up than the processes they are meant to support.

That is no reproach. Every organisation does that when work runs across a boundary nobody drew. And the reason for putting several disciplines around it is sound too. A compound question will not resolve from one lens. Whoever looks only through the lens of their own domain comes back with a partial answer. So an organisation puts HR, IT, finance and the line around one table. That is a good reflex.

A steering group is not a stopgap

More than eighty percent of 256 firms in 23 countries use committees as an ordinary mechanism to gather input. An instrument that four in five organisations use and that sits at the top of the minimal baseline is not a stopgap. Whoever calls it that is using the word wrongly.

The distinction therefore lies in what the body does with the capacity to decide, and not in its form.

The question that decides

Does this table take control capacity away from where the demands land?

A table that decides what has to happen in another unit does. The demands rise there, and the room to meet them has just moved to the table. That is the same imbalance that sits under every seam: the demand lands where the capacity to do something about it has just been removed.

A table that enriches understanding and weighs arguments against each other does not. It adds lenses and leaves the decision where the control capacity sits.

Two tables with the same people and the same agenda can produce a very different organisation. That depends on who decides afterwards.

Which boundary sits underneath

Which answer fits depends on what has to cross the boundary.

If only information has to cross, a table or a form is exactly right, and there is nothing to move. Make it fast and predictable.

If the same words mean something different on either side, an urgent request, a simple change, a finished result, then making sense of it together is the work itself. A multidisciplinary table is the right instrument for that.

If somebody has to give something up, authority, budget, people or the certainty that their own number keeps adding up, no table holds. Every member is held to account by their own department again after the meeting. Then the answer is a team or a moved boundary.

What you can check yourself

  • Do the people at that table speak to each other about the same work outside it?
  • Was the last decision about the work of the people present?
  • Did the unit that has to carry it out get room as well, and not just a demand?
  • Can everyone at the table say why that table exists?
  • Is there a date on which it stops?

Five times no is no disgrace. It is a map of the design still to be made. The fourth question is not the least: in governance research the strongest predictor of a working set-up is not the structure, but whether the people in it can describe it accurately.

How we go about it

We start from your strategic plan and from how work and information run through your organisation today. From that follows where the seams are and which of them still have a reason. We make the design with a group from your own people, because whoever has to carry a change helps design it.

We do not fill roles and we do not take work over. We stop when the new way of working is the ordinary way of working. Read more about how we work →

When this helps

This helps when a new body appears every quarter and the lead time does not get shorter. And above all when you are about to set one up again. Look at the attendance list of the last one first, because it already shows who should be working together. If you cannot tell whether that table replaces the design or adds to it, look at who decides afterwards. That is where the whole difference sits.

Which handover or which board exists at your organisation mainly because it has always been there?

In a 30 minute conversation we look at where the seams in your organisation are and which of them still have a reason.