Frame 1 · Three layers
Position, interest, need
What somebody says is the top layer. Why it matters sits underneath. What somebody really needs sits deepest. That is where it overlaps with the other.
What somebody says is the position. Why it matters is the interest. What somebody really needs is the need. Positions collide. Needs rarely do. Asking on is the way from the one to the other.
A position is a solution somebody has already chosen: “I am not taking part”, “this has to go through my team”. Negotiating over that yields little, because two chosen solutions rarely leave room. Under the position sits the interest: why that solution matters to this person. And under that sits the need: what somebody really needs, apart from any solution. At that level the conversation opens, because a need is universal: there are only a limited number to name, so the same need is often in play on both sides.
Asking on is not an interrogation. It is really wanting to know what is at stake for the other. These questions help:
Watch the form: questions that begin with “what” work better than questions with “why”. “Why do you want that?” quickly sounds like a reproach and pushes people back into their position. “What makes that important to you?” invites.
You recognise a need by three things. It can be put positively: not “I do not want this”, but “I need certainty about my role”. It stands apart from any one solution: the same need can be met in several ways. And it is shareable: whoever says their need out loud often discovers that the other side needs something similar. That is the moment when people who were facing each other begin to look for solutions together.
The most common step is stopping too early. Whoever arrives at the interest often thinks the conversation is done. But an interest is still tied to the situation, and can still stand opposite another interest. Only at the level of the need does the overlap appear. The second trap is solving too fast: making a proposal at the first sign of a need. Well meant, but the other feels cut off instead of heard. Let the need come onto the table in full first. The solution comes after that, and usually from the people involved themselves.
This asking on is the heart of how we work, in every conversation we support. We take positions apart until the interests and needs underneath are visible, and we make visible the shared needs on which people can go on together. Read more about how we work →
Everywhere positions collide and the conversation keeps getting stuck. In a team meeting where the same discussion returns. In a conversation with somebody who is “just against it”. Or between two people each defending their own solution. The technique is small enough to try tomorrow, in the next conversation where you notice you are negotiating over positions.
Then a conversation is the quickest way to see which needs sit under the positions in your situation.