Model

Ideas without judgement

As soon as the shared needs are visible, the question comes: so what do we do now? The biggest trap is not a shortage of ideas, but judgement that arrives too early. Every idea that gets weighed straight away is the last one anybody says out loud.

the idea hits the wall
Frame 1 · The trap

Judgement comes too early

An idea is spoken and weighed on the spot. To the speaker that feels like a rejection, and the next idea stays inside.

now: gather later: weigh
Frame 2 · The separation

Think up first, judge later

Two movements, two moments. The first opens and gathers. The second closes and chooses. Whoever keeps them apart gets both right.

everything may be there for a while
Frame 3 · Quantity

Many ideas, large and small

Ten ideas of which eight fall away yield more than two cautious ones. The good ones rarely come first, so give them the time to arrive.

the usable core inside it
Frame 4 · The core

The odd idea carries a core

The unlikely idea rarely becomes the answer itself. But what sits inside it often points at a direction nobody else saw. That is why it may be there.

the shared needs
Frame 5 · The ground

Ideas grow on the needs

Do not search from positions, because that becomes a compromise, but from the shared needs. There you find possibilities that meet several at once.

choosing together, later
Frame 6 · Only after that

Weighing comes later, and then together

Once the harvest is in, the people involved weigh it themselves: what meets everybody’s needs? That choosing is the next phase, and it is ready for it.

What this is about

As soon as the shared needs are visible, the question comes: so what do we do now? The biggest trap in that step is not a shortage of ideas. It is judgement that arrives too early. Every idea that gets weighed straight away is the last idea anybody says out loud.

Why judging early turns off the tap

Thinking up and judging are two different movements. The first opens: the more the better, the half-baked and the unlikely included. The second closes: weighing, choosing, cutting. Whoever does both at once gets neither right. And in a conflict that counts double: a rejected idea quickly feels like a rejected person there, and then thinking along stops altogether.

How the gathering works

  • Quantity first, quality after. Ten ideas of which eight fall away yield more than two cautious ones. The good ideas rarely come first.
  • An idea is not a decision yet. Writing something down commits to nothing. That certainty makes it safe to say what is only half finished.
  • The unlikely idea often carries a usable core. The idea itself does not become the answer, but what sits inside it points at a direction nobody else saw.

From the needs, not from the positions

The difference with negotiating sits in the starting point. Whoever searches from positions searches for a compromise: everybody gives something up. Whoever searches from the shared needs searches for possibilities that meet several needs at once, and those exist more often than the people involved thought possible. That is why this phase only comes after finding what sits underneath: the needs are the ground on which the ideas grow.

How we go about it

We guard the separation: gather first, weigh later. The ideas come from the people involved themselves, because they know their situation and they are the ones who will have to work with it. Our work is keeping open the room in which the half-baked idea may be heard as well. Read more about how we work →

When this insight helps

In every mediation, and in every meeting where solutions are sought. If you notice that every proposal is shot down on the spot and that fewer and fewer proposals come, then thinking up and judging are running into each other. The remedy is simple to agree: now we gather, later we weigh.

Does every proposal die on the spot with you?

Then thinking up and judging are probably running into each other. In a conversation we look at how you keep the two apart.