Model

Conflict during a reorganisation

A reorganisation divides things up: roles, places, responsibilities. As long as that dividing is under way, everybody defends their own place. The collisions that follow are rarely about the plan. They are about what the plan means for each of them.

not every place is settled yet
Frame 1 · The dividing

Places that shift

A reorganisation reassigns roles, places and responsibilities. Some places are already settled, others are not. As long as the dividing is under way, nothing is neutral.

everybody holds on to their place
Frame 2 · The reaction

Everybody holds on to their place

As long as the dividing is under way, something personal is at stake for everybody. People defend their place, even when nobody is threatening it in so many words.

the plan the attention points at the places
Frame 3 · The disguise

It looks like it is about the plan

The discussion turns to the ground that can be discussed: the content of the plan. But the attention of the people involved points at their place, not at the plan.

“this plan is wrong” what does this mean for me?
Frame 4 · The question underneath

What does this mean for me?

Under every fierce position about the plan sits the same unspoken question. Whoever gets that question onto the table sees the fierceness shrink to its real size.

what it means for each of them the plan in that order
Frame 5 · The order

People first, then the plan

Not defending the plan and seeing who grumbles, but first hearing the personal question of each person involved and letting it weigh. After that the conversation about the plan is really about the plan.

filled in together
Frame 6 · The outcome

Places that are carried

Once the personal questions have been heard and weigh, the dividing finishes. The places colour in fully: not imposed, but filled in together.

What this is about

A reorganisation divides things up. Roles, places and responsibilities are reassigned, and as long as that dividing is under way, something personal is at stake for everybody. The conflicts that surface then look like they are about the plan. But whoever looks closely sees people each defending their place in a division that is not finished.

Why it collides

As long as the dividing is under way, everybody reads the plan through one lens: what does this mean for me. A discussion about the new team structure is then rarely a discussion about team structures. It is about who will sit where, with whom, and under whom. Because nobody says that out loud, the fight takes place on the ground that can be discussed: the content of the plan. The plan takes the blows that are really about the places.

That also explains why those discussions are so hard to win with arguments. Whoever meets a better argument but does not know their place simply moves the fight to the next item on the agenda.

How you recognise it

  • The objections jump around. Today the team structure is wrong, tomorrow the timing, the day after the budget. Jumping objections usually mean one underlying question that is being left unanswered.
  • The fierceness does not match the subject. A detail in the plan calls up a reaction far bigger than the detail. The reaction belongs to what sits underneath, and that is personal.
  • People question the process instead of the content. Who decides this, why so fast, who was heard. Process questions are often questions about places in disguise.

What works

Turn the order around. Not defending the plan first and then seeing who still grumbles, but putting the personal question on the table per person first: what does this mean for you, and what do you need to be able to go along with it. Often the answer is more modest than the fierceness suggested: certainty about a role, the prospect of a conversation, recognition for what somebody built. Only once those questions have been heard can it be about the plan itself, and then it really is about the plan.

If groups already stand opposite each other and every conversation becomes an extension of the last collision, a neutral third party who gives the conversation structure helps. Not to defend or attack the plan, but to make discussable the personal questions that are blocking it.

How we go about it

In a reorganisation conflict we look at the dividing first, not at the plan. With the people involved we bring up the personal questions that sit under the discussion about the plan, and we make sure they weigh. That way the conversation shifts from defending places to filling them in together. Read more about how we work →

When this insight helps

During a reorganisation where the discussions grow fiercer and keep jumping around. Just before the announcement, to know what to watch for. Or months in, when the plan is technically finished but the resistance does not subside. In every case the way out starts in the same place: with the question of what the dividing means for each of the people involved.

Is your reorganisation stuck in discussions?

Then a conversation is the quickest way to see which personal questions sit under the discussion about the plan.