Model

When leadership wants it and the team does not

Leadership has a point: something has to happen. The team has a point: this is not the way. Two reasonable positions that keep each other going, because every push proves to the other side exactly what it already thought.

“you have to come along” “you are not listening” both reasonable, together stuck fast
Frame 1 · Two sides

Two reasonable positions

“You have to come along” against “you are not listening”. Both sound reasonable to whoever says them. And still it is stuck fast.

leadership team the loop keeps turning
Frame 2 · The loop

Every push feeds the push back

The harder one side pushes, the more the other side sees proof of what it already thought. Both react logically to what they see, and that is exactly why the loop keeps turning.

a proposal the proposal turns with the loop
Frame 3 · The move

Every proposal is read as a move

A better plan or a concession does not break the loop. If it comes from leadership, the team hears pressure. If it comes from the team, leadership hears delay.

the position the position results and pace workability, recognition
Frame 4 · Underneath

Under every position a need

Leadership needs results and pace. The team needs workability and recognition. Those needs do not contradict each other. The positions do.

outside the loop, with both
Frame 5 · Outside the loop

A neutral third party opens the conversation

Inside the loop every invitation is itself a move. A neutral third party, accepted by both sides, opens the conversation outside the loop: each story first, then the needs.

that it works, for both the shared core
Frame 6 · The core

Both want it to work

Under the crossed positions lies a shared core. Once that is visible, a proposal becomes an ordinary proposal again, and both sides build the way back themselves.

What this is about

Leadership has a point: something has to happen, and the pace counts. The team has a point: this is not the way, and nobody is listening. Two reasonable positions, and still it is stuck fast. That is down to the loop: every push from one side proves to the other side exactly what it already thought.

Why the loop feeds itself

The harder leadership pushes, the more the team sees proof that nobody is listening, and the firmer it digs in. The firmer the team digs in, the more leadership sees proof that the team does not want to come along, and the harder it pushes. Both sides react entirely logically to what they see. And that is exactly why the loop keeps turning.

Inside the loop the content loses its force as well. A better plan, an extra explanation, a concession: every proposal is read as a move. If it comes from leadership, the team hears pressure in it. If it comes from the team, leadership hears delay in it. More explanation does not break the loop, because the loop does not sit in the content.

How you recognise the loop

  • Both sides can predict exactly what the other is going to say. And they are proved right, every time. Predictability is the mark of a conversation that repeats itself.
  • Every approach is weighed on the sender. What counts is not what is proposed, but who proposes it and what might sit behind it.
  • Both sides feel they are the reasonable one. Ask them separately and you hear the same thing twice: we are moving, they are not.

What breaks the loop

Not another push, and not a better plan either. The loop breaks at the level where it does not turn: the needs under both positions. Leadership needs results and pace, and often also certainty that the organisation can keep up. The team needs workability, and recognition for what it already carries today. Those needs do not contradict each other. More than that: they share a core, because both sides want it to work.

Having that conversation rarely succeeds inside the loop on your own strength, because every invitation to it is itself read as a move. A neutral third party, accepted by both sides, can open the conversation outside the loop: each story separately and in full first, then the needs side by side, and only after that back to the content. From that point a proposal is an ordinary proposal again.

How we go about it

We do not take a side, not silently either. We bring up the needs that sit under the positions with leadership and with the team, and we make the shared core visible: that it has to work, for both. From there the people involved build their own way back to the content. Read more about how we work →

When this insight helps

When the conversations between leadership and team repeat themselves and every attempt at approach seems to make it worse. When you stand between the two yourself and notice you are being read as a camp by one of them. Or beforehand, to recognise when a firm discussion starts turning into a loop, because the shorter the loop has been turning, the easier it opens.

Does the conversation turn in the same loop with you?

Then a conversation is the quickest way to see which needs sit under both positions.