Model

Can this be mediated?

Not every conflict belongs at a mediation table, and that may be said out loud. Four yeses decide whether mediation stands a chance. Checking that beforehand saves everyone a route that leads nowhere.

timing set-up participants
Frame 1 · The exploratory conversation

Meeting the person who asks

Everything begins with whoever requests the mediation, usually without the other participants yet. Together we arrange the session: the timing, the set-up, and who takes part.

the relation decides the set-up
Frame 2 · Balance

Who faces whom?

We map the relations: inside a team, team against team, or team against manager. There has to be balance at the table, whatever the position or the numbers.

the conflict four times yes?
Frame 3 · The question

Does mediation fit here?

In that same conversation we ask the honest question: can this conflict be mediated? The answer shows in four questions, and all four have to be yes.

yes, this is our problem yes, we want to solve it yes, through mediation yes, with this mediator all four, or it rubs
Frame 4 · The four yeses

Four questions, four times yes

The participants say them themselves, at the latest at the start of the first session: this is our problem, we want to solve it, we choose mediation, and we trust this mediator.

somebody wants a ruling the decision is already made it is not safe enough here then no is the honest answer
Frame 5 · When there is a no

Sometimes no is the honest answer

If the exploratory conversation already shows a no on one of the four, the first session makes no sense. A no sounds like this, for example: somebody wants a ruling, the decision is already made, or it is not safe enough here.

“I choose to be here”
Frame 6 · Voluntary

The door is open, nobody pushes

The heart of what we tell the person who asks: the four yeses are only worth something when they are given freely. Not: my boss sent me. Rather: I choose to be here.

What this is about

Not every conflict can be mediated, and that may be said out loud. Mediation works when the people involved want to build the outcome themselves. Whether that is the case shows in four questions, and all four have to be answered yes. Checking that beforehand saves everyone a route that leads nowhere.

The exploratory conversation

It begins with meeting the person who requests the mediation. Usually the other participants are not there, and they do not need to be. In this conversation we settle the practical side of the mediation session: the timing, the set-up, and who takes part. Depending on the number of participants and the complexity, you can count on four to six sessions of two to four hours.

We also look at how the sides relate to each other. Is this a conflict inside a team, between two teams, or between a team and a manager? That relation decides how we set up the session, because there has to be balance at the table: everybody must be able to speak freely, whatever their position or numbers.

And the conversation lays the ground for the four yeses. The participants say them themselves, later. But if it already shows here that there is a no on one of the four, the first mediation session makes no sense, and that is valuable information. So we also ask after how voluntary the participation is. The heart of what we tell the person who asks: it does not work when people come because their boss sent them. It works when each of them can say: I choose to be here.

Four times yes

The four yeses come from the participants in the mediation themselves. Nobody can give them in their place, not even the person who requested it. At the latest at the start of the first session all four have to be there, out loud and given freely.

  • Yes, this is our problem. Both sides acknowledge there really is a conflict. As long as one side maintains that nothing is wrong, there is nothing to mediate.
  • Yes, we want to solve it. Everybody has the will to reach a solution. That is something other than already agreeing on what it looks like.
  • Yes, we want to do this through mediation. The sides deliberately choose mediation, instead of, say, a legal procedure or a decision from above.
  • Yes, we want to work with this mediator. There is trust in the person supporting the process. Without that trust every intervention is weighed instead of used.

When mediation does not fit

Sometimes somebody does not want an outcome but a ruling: being proved right, a judgement, a precedent. That is a legitimate wish, it simply does not belong at a mediation table. Sometimes the decision has actually already been made and mediation is used to wrap it acceptably; that undermines the conversation and always comes out. And sometimes the situation is not safe enough to speak freely. In each of those cases no is the honest answer.

How we go about it

We do not start a route before the four yeses are there. In the exploratory conversation we go through them together, and we say so when one is missing. Better an honest no beforehand than a route that runs aground. Read more about how we work →

When this insight helps

When you are considering proposing mediation and want to judge whether it stands a chance. When one of the people involved hesitates and wants to know what that yes or no is actually about. Or when an earlier route led nowhere and you want to understand why: often one of the four yeses was already missing at the start.

Do you doubt whether mediation fits here?

Then an exploratory conversation is the simplest way to go through the four yeses together, with no obligation.