Model

From positions to a shared vision

A vision is not a slogan on the first slide. It is a compass for decisions, and it only works if the people who have to carry it out really recognise it as their own story.

SPONSOR A SPONSOR B no shared compass
Frame 1 · The missing compass

Without a shared vision, no direction

Every steering group member decides from their own priority. Stakeholders hear contradictory stories. Nobody can explain clearly why this change is needed now. The compass is missing.

SPONSOR A SPONSOR B control costs reduce workload
Frame 2 · Positions at the table

Two sponsors, two priorities

The finance director wants costs under control. The operations director wants the workload down. Two positions, above the waterline, far apart. In reality the whole steering group is at the table.

SPONSOR A SPONSOR B ageing systems pressure from the board overloaded team growing waiting lists
Frame 3 · The case for change

At the interest, the why now becomes clear

Only when you name each sponsor’s interest does it become clear why this project is needed now. That is the case for change: not an abstract story, but each sponsor’s concrete reason.

SPONSOR A SPONSOR B ageing systems credibility
Frame 4 · Sponsor A’s need

What sits under that?

The finance director knows his interest: ageing systems and pressure from the board. But what sits under it? Staying credible with the board. That is his need.

SPONSOR A SPONSOR B overloaded team manageable work
Frame 5 · Sponsor B’s need

The same question, on the other side

The operations director: his team is overloaded, the waiting lists are growing. What sits under it? An organisation where the work stays manageable. That is his need.

staying on its feet the shared vision
Frame 6 · The vision from the overlap

The overlapping part, in one sentence

Both of them want an organisation that stays on its feet. That shared part is not a compromise, it is the source of the vision. In one sentence: we are building an organisation that stays financially healthy, and where the team can keep handling the work.

What this is about

A change without a shared vision is a change without a compass. Sponsors decide from their own interest, stakeholders hear contradictory stories, and nobody can explain why this is needed now. A shared vision solves that, but only if it is built on what the steering group members genuinely share.

Why a vision from above does not work

The classic approach: someone writes a vision statement, the steering group approves it, and it appears on slide two of every presentation. The problem is not the wording. The problem is that nobody recognises it as their own. The finance director does not read their own worry in it. The operations director does not recognise their own urgency. They carry it out because they have to, not because they feel it.

You notice that quickly. When stakeholders ask questions about the direction, the sponsors each give a different answer. Not because they disagree, but because the vision was never really theirs.

How you reach a vision that is carried

You do not start with the wording, but with the positions of the steering group members. The finance director wants costs under control. The operations director wants the workload down. Those are positions, and they are far apart. But under them sits something else.

The finance director’s interest is more concrete: ageing systems and pressure from the board. His need: staying credible with that board. The operations director’s interest: an overloaded team, growing waiting lists. His need: an organisation where the work stays manageable.

At the level of needs, something appears that was invisible at the level of positions. Both of them want an organisation that stays on its feet, in a few years as well. That shared part is the source of the vision. Not a compromise, but the overlapping part, in one sentence: "We are building an organisation that stays financially healthy, and where the team can keep handling the work."

How we go about it

We bring the steering group members together in a workshop, not to convince them of a vision written in advance, but to surface something they have in common. We go through the layers with each of them: what is your position, what sits under it, and what do you really need? Only when that picture is complete do we formulate the vision together, from the overlapping part. So that every sponsor tells the story authentically, from their own role. Read more about how we work →

When this model helps

This works at the start of a change, when the steering group has to agree on direction and message. It is also useful when a change is already running but the sponsors each tell a different story. At that point, going back to the shared need is the quickest way to pick up the compass again.

Do you recognise this in your steering group?

Then a conversation is the quickest way to see how you get from diverging positions to a shared vision.