Foundation

Positions, interests and needs

People stand far apart in a change. But a position is never the whole story. Under it sits an interest, and deeper a need. Whoever hears those from each other finds a way that was not visible before.

POSITION A POSITION B
Frame 1 · Two positions

What you see sits above the waterline

In a change you have at least two sides. One sets it in motion, the other lives through it. Each has a position. That is what you hear, what sits above the waterline. And those positions are often far apart.

POSITION A POSITION B interest need interest need
Frame 2 · The iceberg

A position is the tip

What somebody says is not the reason. Under every position sits an interest: what makes this position matter to this person, what they hope for and what they fear. And deeper a need, and that one is universal. Peace of mind. Recognition. Certainty.

POSITION A POSITION B the software has to go continuity peace of mind
Frame 3 · First side

What is going on with the initiator?

A director wants to replace ageing software. That is his position. His interest: the software is outdated and hard to maintain. His need: stability and peace of mind, the sense that the company is keeping up.

POSITION A POSITION B takes longer years of knowledge recognition
Frame 4 · Second side

What is going on with the people affected?

The staff say: our work is going to take much longer. That is their position. Their interest: the knowledge they have built up over years. Their need: recognition for what they do well, and certainty about what comes next.

POSITION A POSITION B stability
Frame 5 · The overlap

A need is universal

Positions rule each other out. Needs rarely do, because there are only a limited number to name. Both have a need for stability in play, they simply looked at the solution differently. Once they hear that from each other, they see the common ground.

stability supported solutions
Frame 6 · The way forward

From being heard to solutions

Once each has heard what matters to the other, the conversation shifts. No longer: who is right? But: how do we make the transition gradual, how does the knowledge get passed on, how is everybody involved?

What this is about

In every change there are people who set it in motion and people who experience it as something coming at them. They state their positions. Those positions are rarely anywhere near each other, and they do not explain why anyone is for or against something. They are the tip of an iceberg.

Positions do not tell the whole story

A position is the stance someone takes: "that software has to go" or "our work is going to take much longer because of it". It is what someone says out loud, what you can measure and compare. But it is not the reason. The reason sits deeper.

Under a position sits an interest: what makes this position matter to this person. What do they hope for, and what do they fear if it goes another way? Stability. Continuity. Recognition for what has been running well for years. And deeper, under that interest, sits a need: the human thing underneath. Peace of mind. The feeling of still counting for something. Certainty about the future.

As long as you only respond to positions, you go round in circles. Try to convince the other side you are right and you push them further away. The resistance grows, it does not shrink.

What changes when you go deeper

Positions collide. Interests and needs rarely do, and there is a reason for that. A need is universal: there are only a limited number to name, such as certainty, recognition, peace of mind or a say over your own work. The deeper you get under the position, the larger the chance that the same need is in play on both sides. In the software example that need is stability, for the director and for the employees, they simply looked at the solution differently. That shared part only starts to work once both have heard it from each other. Then people see the common ground, and from that point solutions come into view that were not there before.

That takes listening with a different intent. Not waiting for your own turn. Not looking for the weak point in the other side’s story. Asking questions to understand what is really going on, and then saying it out loud. That is what opens people up.

How we go about it

We enter the conversation with each of the people involved as a neutral third party. Not to list positions, but to find the interests and needs underneath. We do that in a structured way, apart from the hierarchy, and with both sides. Only once both sides have heard what matters to the other do we look for solutions together. Read more about how we work →

When this model helps

This is the starting point for every change where people disagree. It works as well for a one to one between a manager and an employee as for a whole team that has to take on a new way of working. As soon as you notice the conversation getting stuck on positions and repetition, this is how you get it moving again.

Do you recognise this pattern in your change?

Then a conversation is the quickest way to see what sits under the positions, and how to find a way forward together from there.