The same words, a different effect
Picture this: a reorganisation is announced. The text is carefully written, the facts are right, the tone is respectful. But the message is brought by someone who does not know the team, who was not there last time, and who has no answer to the questions that really matter. The words are the same. The effect is entirely different from what it would have been if their own manager had said them.
Two axes: expertise and trust
Whether a messenger is credible for a particular group depends on two things. Expertise: does this person know enough about the subject to be taken seriously? And trust: is the audience well disposed towards this person? You need both. One is not enough.
Someone with a lot of expertise but little trust comes across as technically correct but distant. Someone with a lot of trust but little expertise comes across as likeable but not credible. The strongest messenger scores on both, for that specific group.
Four situations, four approaches
Someone who scores high on expertise and trust you use as the primary voice. Someone high on expertise but low on trust you pair with a trusted local colleague who brings the message together with them. Someone high on trust but low on expertise you provide with concrete talking points so the content is right. And someone low on both you do not use as sender, whatever their title or function.
The change manager is rarely the best sender
This is the insight that is hardest to accept. The change manager writes the messages, designs the plan, knows the change inside out. But for most audiences the change manager is not the most credible voice. That is their own manager, or a sponsor who knows the team, or a colleague who tried the new way of working first.
The change manager’s role is not to be the voice, but to design the conditions under which the right voice says the right thing at the right moment. Architect of the communication, not the messenger.
Coaching, not scripting
Whoever acts as the voice does not get a written text to read out. We coach that person so the message comes from within. We do that through the same principle as with the shared vision: their own interest and need, and that of their team or department, gets a place alongside the goals of the organisation. So that the core of the message is correct and carried by authenticity, not by a script.
What this means in practice
Before we draw up a communication plan, we map out per audience who the credible voice is and what that person needs. Sometimes it is a manager who needs coaching to bring a difficult message. Sometimes it is a colleague on the floor with a lot of informal influence who still lacks the context. That assessment decides which support we build in before the communication starts. Read more about how we work →
Why this matters
When surveying the ground you map not only who is affected and how heavily. You also map whether the organisation has the right voices to carry the change. Are the managers credible enough for their teams? Do sponsors have the skills to bring a difficult message? Where is coaching or training needed before the communication starts?
Judging that up front makes the difference. When the readiness heatmap turns the communication dimension red or amber, this is where you look: is the problem the message, or who brings it? Often it is the second. And you want to know that before you write a communication plan, not after.